Does anyone else find this album overrated?

I do. I love Radiohead, but "In Rainbows" isn't their strongest offering. About a year or so before this album came out Radiohead leaked a few live songs from this album. One of them being "Arpeggi" or "Wierd Fishes/Arpeggi" as it is called on "In Rainbows". Anyway, if you can find that version you will see why I was a wee bit let down. It's one of those unusual circumstances where the live version is better than the album. Hmm, so sad, but that's ok, Radiohead is nowhere near done with their brilliance. I'm sure of it.